Why e-learning is killing education | Aaron Barth

Video quality	The size	Download

Information Why e-learning is killing education | Aaron Barth | TEDxKitchenerED

Title	:	Why e-learning is killing education \| Aaron Barth \| TEDxKitchenerED
Lasting	:	8.39
Date of publication	:
Views	:	345 rb

This is not groundbreaking information Every Learning Designer knows this and fights this fight every day We believe in holistic learning experiences that are scenario based, problem based and incorporate active learning experiences unfortunately that is not how corporates and our clients think - as these scenario based and adaptive models are expensive and take longer to develop I always will use a scenario based model over a click model and I'm sorry but no one is using an avatar speaking in front of bulletpoints anymore well not Learning designers that have actual qualifications in learning
Comment from : Daniela B

This is why I love e-learning and why I struggle in school, it offers flexibility for me to be able to take my time and actually think about/ reflect on what I have learned (or observed if in a lecture) and think about applications of the info and try my best to look for errors in the thinking Basically, yes storytelling is great, but for me flexibility to pace myself so I can make sure I fully understand before moving on completely is most important (FOR ME) :)
Comment from : sauceWHY

The technology is problematic because the internet is still quite new and it involves so many moving parts They are rushing into online learning too quickly And the UI and security measures are a hindrance to learning Because they take up too much time and energy that aren't relevant to the learning
Comment from : Robbie

What u r basically saying is we need to incorporate artificial emotional intelligence into the e-learning platform
Comment from : Socrates Muyambo

We're seeing you by distance though
Comment from : Leandro Gonzaga

As a high school shop teacher - I agree 100 with Aaron!brAlso, if we were to imagine a world where all learning was done online, we wouldn't need schools anymore and the most valuable thing schools have is LAND!!!! SO much LAND!! So much money for governments to make!
Comment from : Jane Davis

Not to be overlooked: The bank needs a simple job aid with images of valid ID forms right at the teller station
Comment from : Daniel Holthouse

Yeah the tide is turning against e-learning
Comment from : KByouknowbaby

The fluff on his jacket is triggering my OCD!
Comment from : NoLefTurnUnStoned

Blaming the car for the death of the horse and carriage
Comment from : thabiso mbingo

Stories are useful, but only useful in engaging the student with the content Like gaming, you learn the controls and strategies but it's the story that gets you to keep going, because you want to learn what will happen nextbrbrThe real point I'm making is that some people keep stories in themselves, and can engage with the content on their own Not everyone is as unmotivated or uncreative as most students, which usually happens 'because' of educationbrbrLet learning evolve
Comment from : Korsy the Flexivore

Great presentation I agree Interweaving the human element through story telling will resonate with the learners
Comment from : Dwight Fallin

interesting TEDx
Comment from : Coffee Lover

I agree that scenario or story-based learning can teach people better
Comment from : Wong PLin

e-learning complements education brnot killing education! brbecause some people cannot access traditional education
Comment from : wida 123

eLearning is great if you want a online certification Any serious degree program exp is cheapened on eLearning It's not the same as in person live exp with an experienced professor who can tell you real stories that connect with the course material I can speak from personal experience having taken Uni course in class and in eLearning e-Learning also takes up far more time and energy as you spend more time figuring out what needs to be done Vs doing the actual work I made As in my eLearning classes but I dont feel I learned much as I can't recall most of the stuff anymore while my in-person classes from years ago, I still remember the stories my Prof taught I totally Agree with Aron Barth !
Comment from : AC

I homeschool and we use e-learning and paper Stories are fun, but if you don't have time, the most important part of the stories are the analogies Eduation went down way before e-learning The biggest downfall was the imposition of Common Core I went to elementary school in the 60's Nowadays, spelling books (or online) don't teach spelling rules and math books (or online) don't drill basic arithmetic We learned by rote and I can still add, muliply and divide without a calculator And, as you can see, my grammar is still pretty good, too 🙂
Comment from : Laura Jane

Anyone from ENGGEN 403?
Comment from : Haoyu Zhang

Let us not as why let us just praise Jesus
Comment from : TRUE AUTHOR Ity

2:07br2:36- 3:02
Comment from : Jennie Gem

Why inability of teachers to "storytell" in the way they teach is killing education | Aaron Barth | TEDxKitchenerED
Comment from : Hadi Saputra

We learned through story tellingbrLearning is about people!
Comment from : Shresth Aditya

im hoping we have what neo had in teh marix i can just plug in a usb into my brain and download all the info i need
Comment from : Joe Swanson

Nope That's what YOUR eLearning looks like, not mine The speaker lost credibility as an eLearning developer the moment he said that he was a lecturer with no eLearning experience That's like expecting a dentist to perform heart surgery
Comment from : uacbpa

Online education works if you got a great theater system
Comment from : Phuc-Hoang, Anh-Tu

"accelerate time to expertise" another one
Comment from : Mar Science

"between the caves and the clicking"
Comment from : Mar Science

It’s very ineffective right now, You could be in a disadvantage if you’re addicted to the internet or worse prnographic content, I wanted face-to-face to return
Comment from : 7he7ast70ner

Screw all of you who think that distance learning is bad, that distance learning year was the best year for me and all of my classes were all A+!
Comment from : ARAV CHOPRA

Very good
Comment from : ca ta

Online education gives power knowledge and money without the hassles of interveiw the companies future insights
Comment from : PANKAJ BAJAJ

Filling buckets with facts, not storytelling with imagination, metaphor, emotion, lighting fires, drama, conflict, paradox, analogy, catharsis, etcetcetc that's the problem!
Comment from : Susan McDonald

You can empower people by telling stories online You do that here in this video However, your anecdotal cited example does not refer to an actual online training (or if it does you do not specify which one) So the very evidence that you say to support your argument has not occurred in a documented way What I am hearing is an unsupported complaint against online education and an argument to keep the existing transmission style of education in place Our learners are changing in how they learn and our educational systems need to adapt Online learning is one of those adaptations
Comment from : Jessica Monte

i hate online class so much, they only show us pdf files and give difficults assignments
Comment from : Joshua Llido

Recognize the irony of this coming out in 3/2020, just before schools everywhere went remote
Comment from : Jump with the Devil

Unfortunately all this TED talk does is illustrate how out of touch Aaron Barth is with the current state of eLearning In fact, many great eLearnings encorporate story telling and scenarios That's not even a new concept, that's been around for years Just because this guy sucks at Instructional Design, doesn't mean that "eLearning is killing education"
Comment from : Ros McNamee

says the guy who has never in his life been in High School in 2022
Comment from : LilOldFazeCancer ForFree

If you turn off video , you can hear iruka sensi 🥷
Comment from : JAY SONAWANE

He just empowered me to get into telling stories again through e learning ted
Comment from : john Kong

We have to re-think education big-time, that's obvious It was already wrong for me If I had the right education my path would have been very different for sure (you might think I could not complain as I have a PhD but with a proper education I would definitely chosen a different path)
Comment from : Chris A

Thank you
Comment from : AA Education

Very interesting and engaging content! Thank you
Comment from : Learning LAB LMS

Because kids in the US are not disciplined and focused to take classes online It’s the American culture and environment on how kids are groomed and raised from a young age Mainly American parents, No discipline taught from a young age That’s why kids are undisciplined and focused Foreign countries, we don’t see this much as a problem It’s the American culture Education is not a priority
Comment from : JJ C

I learnt more during online classes due to self study I don't believe in classroom learning Why should I get yelled at for asking simple questions? I don't want a teacher to yell and me and expect me to learn at the same time I like online and e learning way better because atleast I'm happy and not stressed out
Comment from : Thanos

He lost me at 557 I’m in UK and I’m being told by Putin on a video, the West is being destroyed by woke ism, I happen to agree with Putin I have no idea what this lecturer is talking about Just accept people make mistakes in the workplace Apologise, and learn from it We don’t need a lecture about it
Comment from : AngelH

Can anyone summarize the content of this video? help me, please
Comment from : Sarahln

I'm e-learning this video 😂😂😂
Comment from : Diariesofalobedu girl

Wow really cool content, very entertaining and educational always success for the content, may it bring blessings from the Almighty let's just stop by my channel I'm from Riau-Indonesia
Comment from : IRJUS_ANAK PARIT

All have their perspective
Comment from : Anil Kashyap

im studying on 6th grade and everyone here is getting bad grades due to the online class, its more tiring than presential learning omfg
Comment from : G0og1e Gugz

I don't know but I'm taking e-learning courses to prepare for a tech related certification All I can say is that it is working fine and that the cost I'm paying for it is extremely low compared to taking a class in person I've had teachers in the past who were all about telling stories about what they had accomplished in life It was junior high school instructors, so I'm not sure if that had something to do with that I've had other great teachers, but I've come to the realization that a great deal of what is being taught in schools is very repetitive, if you think of the contents of the same course, year after year, so I'm not sold on the idea that integrating stories would have made a difference in that case this presenter gave as a good reason not to embrace e-learning If anything, it was the bank responsibility to train the bank employees on what constitutes acceptable forms of identification I'm not sure if most other in-person classes would have had the time to teach about this specific situation, as those instructors already have a lot on their plates
Comment from : J S

The real issue with it is that not everyone could do it, some ppl couldn't afford a laptop, some had trouble at home or didn't know what to do
Comment from : VixyMix101

I am a scuba instructor The industry has gone to e-learning as an option and it has done exactly what you presented Not only do the students not learn from it, I usually find that most start guessing just to get the answers so that they can move along to my in-person educational review of that material If it wasn't for my review, they could easily fail the course For what it's worth, I could easily see an attorney use the e-learning program to paint a particular light on the education one received in the event of an accident or injury Better education must be mandatory, not an option
Comment from : JCA ELITE SCUBA

*Advocates against lecture-based education by giving a lecture
Comment from : John Rockwell

Teach Python and Algebra with stories, please
Comment from : Waheed Akhtar

I just cannot learn or take in info online
Comment from : AstroTerra

Didn't listen to the Ted talk but still agreed
Comment from : Giorno Giovanna

I feel like online learning kills the educational during in the pandemic
Comment from : cat pin

When there is no ALTERNATIVE,we have to try and get maximum advantage from them 👍👍👍👍👍,before OFFLINE CLASSES can be STARTED 👍👍👍👍👍
Comment from : LEARN WITH SHOBHA MEHTA

E learning sucks in comparision to in-class studying There's no real engagement in online learning, just reciting a lecture to a quiet audience
Comment from : Evan Voyageur

E-learning is not bad The education system is bad And this is the first sign that you have to fix it
Comment from : CookieMilk

E-learning gives everyone instant free access to varied sources I don't think there's anyone out there who can possibly have an argument against that
Comment from : Lara

E-learning is killing educators, students, and learning itself People are human, not E-human
Comment from : Eray Aktaş

only a few weeks later lmaobrbrEVERYONE HAD TO!
Comment from : ElectronTheNerd

Nice
Comment from : shaon ballav

People like me who have little access to world-class education will concede on one thing that e-learning is a blessing for us
Comment from : Srabon Shaikh

Our teacher used this Ted Talk for our activity during bonline class/bbrbrUhuh yes Ummm I- Yes ehm yes Uhhh
Comment from : Fresh O2

Survey guys!brWhat can you conclude?
Comment from : Pvz2 música española

I assume this was before the pandemic
Comment from : Sai Teach

A very good point here I'm just not sure if it's everything that we need Or is it?!
Comment from : RezaRob3

Can’t believe this was a month before the pandemic
Comment from : Dj Almadrones

Yes
Comment from : Hunter B Hyped

Why is my ad Nas daily?
Comment from : kyle Montera

Digital learning makes my brain commit suicide
Comment from : Robert Gray

moral of the story : dont let bank employees e-learn
Comment from : yash agarwal

Elearning is not the enemy BAD Elearning is !
Comment from : MA FORMATION

"education no matter where you get it, the real problem is what you make of it"br-Someone quoted it on another video
Comment from : hey hey

The ultimate implementinon proponent would be the gospel of Christianity should be the best to lead with
Comment from : Brian

School already has a out-aged dead education that never provides anyone’s needs online school or in reality school will never change
Comment from : PendingName

I thought online classes was the future
Comment from : Fitness Y Más

I think the title was not properly explaining the talks Aaron talkes about the content or method for teaching, not the tools (e-learning itself)
Comment from : Annisa Mursyidah

very good points, and spot-on -- trouble with mainstream "e-learning" today is that it's often done on the cheap, instead of USING the extra tools that are avilable in that format; as in figuring out how to put the "Cone of Learning" study results (Kolbe) into it We forget the lesson content (all "frontal" lesson content) after 20 mins because we just watched a "lesson" passively and did not practice the real thing as part of that low-quality "e-learning" E g a story-based "main video" should be accompanied by "doing the real thing" as an exercise integrated in the course (and incentivized by adding a PDF form to be completed, or similar) That way, we can add what e-learning technology can offer , if done properly
Comment from : eLearningBizTec Webinars

Wat a boreeng
Comment from : zea

Wat a boreeng
Comment from : zea

Wow, I thought people/learner weren't like stories because it was boring or took long time, I thought these days people easy to lost their focus or concentration
Comment from : desy cobena

The real problem is the modern college system hasn’t caught up with the times They keep raising prices and curtailing flexibility to meet the teacher’s needs when they want to teach not when the students want to learn At the end of the day people want cheaper prices and flexibility
Comment from : MDobri2378

Ach halt die fresse du geldgeiles b*********/b
Comment from : Stefan B

E-Learning is the future Make sure you learn the technology skill and teach online
Comment from : Grand Bay Central

I work an 8-5 shift remotely while obtaining my masters in Data Science online I actually like having the opportunity to work remotely and learn online The benefits to me is that I do not have to physically be in a classroom and can move around If I want to travel to a beautiful city while working and studying I can do so To me this has been very beneficial and I have saved tons of money (commuting, clothes, food at work) that I was able to reinvest in the stock market
Comment from : Misha W

Awesome
Comment from : nunya1 Bizness

watching this for English :/
Comment from : Amelia Bennett

It was already killed
Comment from : SoDwi

Stories are the best way to teach anything
Comment from : Jeetu Kotai

This hits different during covid times
Comment from : Jasmine E

1:37 "So how did we get here?"brMe: Do you have 90 minutes?
Comment from : Endless Summer

arrogant
Comment from : fabian troncoso

He is right But the problem is much deeper E-learning has a huge potential But it is not being used to even 50 of what it can do We are simply getting info that is way to theoretical and complex And we cannot apply that information for it to truly make sense and stick Just try taking a IT server or Cisco CCNP education online, without touching any gear, it will drive you insanebrSeriously, the random stuff we all have to remember just to become a Doctor/psychologist/someone studying law is absolutely insane And on top of that doing it online, is enough to make any sane person quit or even worse Something needs to be done
Comment from : Real HIFI Help