Home page

Saurabh Mukherjea on dealing with flak and criticism, and avoiding echo chambers

Frames Saurabh Mukherjea on dealing with flak and criticism, and avoiding echo chambers

Description Saurabh Mukherjea on dealing with flak and criticism, and avoiding echo chambers

Comments Saurabh Mukherjea on dealing with flak and criticism, and avoiding echo chambers

i visited his pms on pms bazar i didn't understand why would any one invest with his pms while returns are not upto the mark instead if some one invested in mid cap or small cap mutual fund return would be quite good without paying extra to this pms Comment from : Krunal Bhavsar

Disappointed by MFs and PMS, I haved decided that I will open my own Mutual Fund Comment from : Smeshnoy Matvey

Baatey zyada kaam kam hai iska😂 Comment from : Paritosh Pandey

Mocery is done when Marcellus rising giants is down 30 percent and still Marcellus has audecity to charge management fees --- day light scam --- rip marcellus Comment from : sanjay jain

Is mukharji bina wajah ki faltu baat karta hai isne titan relaxo v mart retail aur bhi bahut share purchase kra diye aur ek bhi nhi chalta Comment from : AG

His pms is a trap similar to realestate Subdue return, too much marketingbrAt the end return matters irrespective of whether it's coming from mf or pmsbrBetter invest in nifty 50 etf Comment from : Dheeraj Thakur

Interviewer ne to kamal kar diya, khaas taur se echo chamber wala question Comment from : Husain Daud

What a good looking intelligent fellow Comment from : Scarface Capital

Great way how Larissa guided the interview and absolutely very good insights from Saurabh Comment from : AJEEZ SEBASTIAN

Consistent compunder portfolio recovery kar raha hai enka baki sab PMS ki pitae hue hai 😂 Comment from : Mr saurabh kumar

Its better not to blindly follow him His strategy of buying high valuations stocks and most of the time they underperform Comment from : Yugal Patil

Give SM credit for packaging a imaginary moneymaking gravy train by putting up past performance charts, management ratings,etc published in books and in mediathere will never be a shortage of gullible folk in the world Masterclass sales pitch time after time to benefit family and friends Comment from : Mario Gracias

I've seen Suarabh Mukerjea saying that he will generate 10 times returns in 10 years While many other managers like Prasanth Jain, Rajeev Takkar, Nilesh Shah etc just say that they are not sure how much they can generate and they will try their bestbr As a beginner in market I am not sure who is correct But 10x in 10 years if true will be very great I think for that he should generate 5x in next 5 years to achieve the goal of 10x in 10 yearaThat is 39 percentage cagr Comment from : Goutham Kondapavuluru

Amazing Interview! Comment from : Ritesh Bhagwati

he is claerly lying on our face that he is in that top 10, he is fooling guys, please check his pms performance , he is very good in selling, ultimately everyone knows how much u are making Comment from : Gaurav Dewangan

Look at his arrogance while answering despite such poor performance Comment from : Jubair Mazumder

This guy had maligned his image over the past yearbrFund not performing ( in the bottom deciles) , and misleading the investors into buying his portfolio companies, and moving on from them(case in point Relaxo, though I'm not an investor)brUnless his fund starts to perform, he will have a difficult time facing the investor communitybrMarketing, fancy words and presentation skills can only get you so far, people are more aware of the facts now Comment from : Harsh Gadhiya

Most of the MFs have done better than CCP Check last 5 years returns br Unfortunately he believes in BAAPbuy at any priceno respect for market price, valuation wonder what made him buy Berger Paints, Lal Pathlabs , TCS specifically TCS at its worst Comment from : Devesh Maheshwari

While people keep slamming but I have seen many 5 star analysts picking up cues from his research without attributing credit to him Comment from : Partha Mukherjee

Marcellus entire portfolio's is on holiday rather than stocks going on holiday Comment from : vivek shah

I ve compounded my portfolio nearly 23 for the last 9 years listening to all market analysts Comment from : R S

Really nice interview Hard questions and candid answers Comment from : Wisecrackmel MOC

Someone please get his hair fixed Comment from : Baleno

I believe and like many basic principles like ethical company and clean accountingbut one point i don't understand any P/E multiple value at any level investment I think one-time investment may be doesn't matter much p/e value and holding for minimum 10-15 years but SIP mode p/e very much importantAlso one doubt since they publish all there portfolio stocksmay be they sell stock at high price and buy low internally eventhough they claim no selling and stay invested long brI believe br1 Ethical companybr2 Clean managementbr3 Reinventing companybr4 Invest in low price rather at any price Comment from : John Christopher

The problem is not 15 returns that his schemes normally generate, but his Big Bol Bacchan that he would utter 2-3 years back "10X in 10 Years" used to be his favorite line in every webinar or interview to gather AUMbrPeople/viewers will certainly criticize when he promises 26 returns & delivers only 15brAajkal thoda thik ho gayi hai Team Marcellus, around 18 to 20 returns ki baat karne lage hai Comment from : Nirmal Pandey

The saddest part in our lives is the need to see intelligent people having to suffer fools! I saw a comment here offering some statistics about Marcellus being ranked 122 pit of 169 Not sure if this is verified So lets say it is, I would want my money with someone like Saurabh delivering me 15 average returns rather than others who apparently have given higher returns but have very poor investment portfolios consisting of weak stock index stories If these guys have been plain lucky, I am confident given the changing scene in the country, only consistent logic built on clean, well run businesses will yield the returns that retail investors like me would want to see in the long term Comment from : Venkat Pisipaty

Despite all what he is saying which makes sense, most of their portfolios are not able to beat their benchmarks brbrTo make matters worse, there has been a consistent erosion of AUM of Marcellus As per SEBI data on PMS, Marcellus is consistently facing exodus of capital of approximately 110 crores per month from its AUM and this figure is only showing a growing trendbrbrI do appreciate their philosophy  but eventually the end result of investment has to be returns Devoid of returns, no philosophy will make any sense Comment from : G Dsouza

He will fade away Comment from : Vetri Cara

What an incredible interview It's just delightful to hear Saurabh every single time Comment from : Ankith Salian

My friend gave his hard earned money of 50 lacs to marcellus and is trying to just recover his principal since 2 years Shame on you saurabh and your tall claims Do not play with our money Comment from : Anil Prasanna

You can't really buy the same stuff that has done too well in the "past" in the name of quality If you are not giving guaranteed returns, it better to choose those fund managers who truly take the risk to generate alpha brbrActually, these guys haven't seen the lowest-highest commodity cycle ,Infra cycle, and PSU in their careers, which currently is generating relatively far more Alpha brbrWhat perplexes me more is that they now sell their duds a lot around the bottom instead of selling it during euphoria GMM, La Opala, and now Relaxo, either u hold them for another upcoming cycle or try to book when the valuation is exorbitantly higher with overoptimism It's not good when u sell if it corrects around 50 Comment from : Deepesh Sao

Reality is that Mukherjee lies thru his teeth and contorts facts to suit his narrative I don't know about others but i can't trust money to a guy who's intellectually disingenuous brPerformance comes later Comment from : A S

Glad Larissa / You nailed it finally! Comment from : Amar R Thapar

Hat's off to the host this sort of questions were really needed to be asked and i have never seen anyone asking him the tough questions Comment from : Arnab Nandy

Beautifullly done How many times we see Saurabh being interviewed by TV journalists asking him stupid questions and wasting his and viewers’ time! Equally impressed by Saurabh’s unwavering, principled approach to investing We continue to believe in him All the best Comment from : Kumar

Thanks sourav for suggesting best stocks but I do buy when current pe is atleast lower than 5 year median pe Comment from : NILADRI BANERJEE

Rajeev Bajaj, not Rajeev Jain! Comment from : Vishnu Kamath

A poor fund with bad investments Comment from : Eappachan Kandathil

Sir ne jab se Tata Elaxi liye stock wahin pe ruk gaya 😂 Comment from : Sultan A

Always have a pleasure to listen Sourabh MukherjiaThe great author , analystThanks for the views Comment from : DIBYA JYOTI SAIKIA

Excellent questions Comment from : Siddarth mohta

Is so good at marketing that he has fallen for his own BS I did too, and invested in CCS and RG But recently redeemed both at an overall negative return Comment from : Sky Gardens

Now sir is advocating value companies with reasonable price two years back only buy at any price BAAP Comment from : Dr Dillip Dalai

He is honest that is rare That is why we loved him Comment from : Ram

Please please please ask him to buy a better mic Sometimes it becomes a bit difficult to understand what he's saying Comment from : Harshit Thirani

Absolutely loved this side of Saurabh and the line of questioning I'm still a believer in Marcellus Philosophy and I will continue to invest accordingly Wish him well! Comment from : Abhay Shirole

Larissa finally someone had the balls to ask Saurabh Mukherjee some hard facts Kudos to u Comment from : Sankar Sreekumar

We've some impact in modifying our mutual portfolio basing on Saurabh's insights, as we believe he brings logic and workable strategy in articulation but might not be suitable for highly short-term aspirations 😊 Comment from : Satyam-EVA Jayate

All said and done Saurabh’s net worth is several thousand crores and he has ten thousand clients Serious investors pay close attention to his words Plus he is the author of many books Comment from : Vivek Shivdasani

The problem with him, is that he is too hung up on certain product types, and potential growth in the years to come While ignoring the major stories that are developing RIGHT NOW And missing the opportunities to make money Unless this team takes a different stand in the market, with a change in perspective, it doesn't look like they are going to get back in shape And what's wrong with his hair? Just wondering Comment from : Siddharth Ahuja

Who was the cricket team captain and the freedom fighter? Comment from : Shiv Gindodia

I have been an investor in Marcellus' PMS since June 2021 I have seen fund value go up, come down and stay down I am disappointed with the current performance, but I think two years is too early to judge Team Marcellus I have faith and will wait for many more years before changing my mind Thankyou for the interview I hope Team Marcellus will stay on course and will not get rattled by poor performance of their investment funds in the short term Comment from : Raghvinder Joshi

truly a different flavored, insightful interview Thanks to Larissa for asking such direct, yet concise questions, and giving all the time to Saurabh for answering Comment from : Udatto Chatterjee

Saurabh MUKHARJEA is the rahul Gandhi of the stock exchange Comment from : Dr Danesh Irani

10000 crore PMS can earn 200 crore annually on fixed fee structure 200 crore is for giving similar or lower than index returns No doubt they should focus on teaching marketing to students Comment from : Ven

Here are the facts There are 168 mutual fund schemes that have CRISIL rating of 2 or more The average return of these schemes is 185 compared to Marcellus’s consistent compounder PMS return of 159 since its inception (1st December 2018) If a rank is to be given, Marcellus’s CCP would stand 122nd out of 169 So, it seems like they are in the bottom 30 rather than in the top 10 as claimed by Saurabhji Comment from : Ven

This is such an Amazing interview Larissa At a totally different level and straight to the point questions And I reckon Saurabh answered the questions quite eloquently I seriously wonder these sort of videos should have 100 thousand views if not million Thanks Larissa for such an awesome interview brAbhimanyu Comment from : AP

Sourabh is stupid Comment from : Saptarshi

Very good questions and very good answers as expected Comment from : Manoj Warrier

what stocks he suggested????? Comment from : raja raja

Excellent questions asked Comment from : VARUN JAIN

Thanks Comment from : Rajiv Lath

What a wonderful piece of discussion with no bull shit talk Thanks for bringing out such onformative dicussion Comment from : Dinesh Jakhar

Thank you Sourabh for writing great books Comment from : KNEE POINT

I liked this interview brSaurabh comes on Many news channels but but this was different and deep Comment from : abhinav singh

Quality interview, unlike mainstream interviews asking for stock tips Comment from : Meet Nagshetia

Related Saurabh Mukherjea on dealing with flak and criticism, and avoiding echo chambers videos

Plato on Imitation and Art | Mimesis | Literary Criticism РѕС‚ : Learning Literature with Purba Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Avoiding Stamp Duty and Inheritance Tax - Transfer Property to Children РѕС‚ : UK Property Tax Accountants Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Productive and Receptive Skills in the EFL Classroom - Receptive Skills - Avoiding Problems РѕС‚ : ITTT International TEFL u0026 TESOL Training Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

25 BEST Universal Orlando Tips and Tricks: From Saving Money to Avoiding Lines РѕС‚ : The Park Prodigy Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Red Cross CEO addresses criticism of how they use donations РѕС‚ : CBS Mornings Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

A little learning is a dangerous thing by Alexander Pope |An Essay on Criticism| summary u0026 analysis РѕС‚ : English made easy with Swarnshikha Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Avoiding The Love Of Money, By John MacArthur. РѕС‚ : Sola Scriptura: Biblical Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Centre Director Shannon talks about working at an EChO Centre РѕС‚ : Goodstart Early Learning Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

What is the best part about working at an EChO Centre? РѕС‚ : Goodstart Early Learning Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Best Battery Lawn Mower? EGO vs Milwaukee, ECHO, Ryobi, Toro РѕС‚ : Pro Tool Reviews Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time